Skip to main content

Paper Textbook or E-book?


I have to admit that my mind is not settled on this question. I own a Barnes & Noble nook and love to read murder mysteries on it, but my apartment is also filled with paper books. Ultimately, the choice is up to you. Here are some things to think about as you decide which format to buy.

Paper hard copy

Advantages

  • You can use it when the power goes out. You don't need a great computer or Internet connection to read the book. (My home Internet connection, through CenturyLink, has days when it simply stops working—several times for half an hour or so. I could still be reading a paper book when that happens.)
  • You can underline things and write in the margins.1
  • It's yours forever (unless you have rented it).
  • A paper book just feels more like reading to some people.

Disadvantages

  • Paper books do cost more.
  • If you tend to lose things or leave them lying around for people to steal, books are vulnerable.

E-book

Advantages

  • Cheaper
  • You can search the text electronically.
  • The computer can read the text aloud to you.2
  • Even if your computer crashes (or someone steals it), you still have a way to get the text again.

Disadvantages

  • One more thing to learn. Everyone knows how to open a book, but an E-book introduces one more bit of software to understand.
  • To get a paper book, you walk into the campus bookstore and buy it—no further steps are necessary. But to start using an E-book you need to deal with an outside vendor (during a very confusing and busy time in your life).
  • Computer systems in general (and publishers' in particular) get very overloaded at the start of the school year.3
  • Yes, there is a way to "underline" and annotate computer texts, but (again) it's another bit of software to learn. You can't just pick up a highlighter and make a mark.
  • The formatting doesn't look much like a book, and sometimes it fights you.4

Notes:

  1. If you have bought the book, don't be afraid to mark in it. Marking a textbook is a very good way to help you learn. On the other hand, if you have rented the book, look at your rental agreement. Different companies have differing attitudes about highlighting and writing in the margins.
  2. Macmillan (publisher of our textbooks) is very proud of their read-aloud function, but when I tried it, I was very disappointed. Aside from sounding like Marvin the Martian with a mouth full of Gummy Bears, the electronic voice occasionally skips words or parts of words. Both Apple and Windows have much better ways for the computer to read the text aloud to you; use those.
  3. I hope things are better now, but several years ago when we attempted to go 100% E-book for freshman English at the University of Akron, the results were so terrible that the publisher was permanently banned from the English Department. Every student in the country is trying to sign up for E-books at the same time, and everyone who has questions is trying to get through to the publisher's help line.
  4. I looked at the online version for one of our books, America Now, and it was OK when it finally got around to the text, but before that the reader had to wade through a LOT of material which is in the footnotes of the paper book.

Three final thoughts

  • If you buy from the campus bookstore, you get exactly the right thing (and if you keep your receipt, you can get credit if there's a mistake). If you go to some outside seller, you must be very careful to buy exactly the item the course requires.
  • It's quite possible that America Now will be the textbook for your Spring English 101 course. An agreement which only allows you to use it until the end of December might end up costing you more than simply paying for a full school year of access.
  • Writer's Reference (even though it's going to a new edition) is the sort of book you will want to keep around for most of your college career. You would be silly to get rid of it in December, then buy it again in January (then get rid of it in May and buy it again in September).

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Getting Ready to Launch

Hello and welcome to Ashland University English 100.

I am writing this on the last day of Spring semester final exam week, looking forward to a full summer and getting ready for the fall. Even in ordinary times, the summer between high school and college was confusing, frightening, and a little sad. After all, you have to leave a whole lifestyle behind and try to figure out how to become something (and someone) rather new. If you are uncertain whether it will all work, you're not alone.

The whole business with the coronavirus Covid-19 has made things even more strange and uncertain. The last day I saw my students was the day before Spring Break (March 6, 2020). We did the second half of the semester as a distance education course, with nobody on campus. I couldn't even visit my office to retrieve supplies. We really have no way of predicting how things will be in 3½ months—will we be together in class or not? I am just much in the dark as you are. So here is how we will deal w…

Summer Reading I

Summer is a time for some relaxed reading—even more this year than normal because a lot of the typical summer things won't work this year. Hang out with friends? Go to the movies? Swimming pool? Shoot a few hoops? Expedition to the mall? Not going to happen this year. There's just so much Facebook and Twitter that a brain can stand, and the evening news is plain depressing.

I'm going to suggest a few books to read. I assume that your local library and bookstore are closed at the moment, so these are all computer downloads, and they are all free. These are all from Project Gutenberg, which is the home of an incredible number of great books, all free and legal.

Onward we go, in no particular order (these are just a few titles that came to mind as I threw this item together—I'm certain I will think of others later):
The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes by Arthur Conan Doyle (The original murder mystery author)Treasure Island by Robert Louis Stevenson (Long before there was …

Late Preparations

During this last month Look carefully at your class schedule. Mistakes happen, and you will find it much easier to correct them in the week or two before classes start. Do a campus walk-through. We are a small campus, but we are still big enough to be confusing. Some buildings are known by more than one name (a great example is the building our class is in: commonly called Dauch, it's also called COBE, which stands for the College of Business and Economics). Your Monday-Wednesday-Friday schedule is different from your Tuesday-Thursday schedule. Walk both of them and actually find the rooms.Get an eye exam. Don't laugh. At least one student in every section I teach sits in the back, squinting and struggling to see the board. If you need glasses, get them. Wear them. They don't look weird.Go shopping. I assume you'll buy new clothes and such, but don't go overboard. What you wore in high school will probably work in college. Do be aware, though, that your class sched…